1.5 - Reference Frames

Introduction

A reference frame (or frame of reference) is a coordinate system used to describe the position, motion, and other physical properties of objects.

Definition of a Reference Frame:

A reference frame consists of:

  • An origin (a fixed point in space from which positions are measured)
  • A set of coordinate axes (typically three perpendicular axes: $x$, $y$, $z$)
  • A clock (to measure time)
  • A set of measuring instruments (rulers, etc.) attached to the frame

Together, these elements allow us to specify the position $\mathbf{r}(t)$ and other properties of objects as functions of time.

How Reference Frames Can Differ

Different reference frames can differ in several important ways:

1. Position of the Origin

Two reference frames may have their origins at different locations in space. For example, one frame might have its origin at the center of the Earth, while another has its origin at the center of the Sun. The same object will have different position vectors in these two frames, but the relative positions between objects remain consistent.

2. Orientation of the Axes

Reference frames can have their coordinate axes oriented differently. For instance, one frame might have its $z$-axis pointing upward, while another has its $z$-axis pointing downward. The axes can also be rotated relative to each other. The same vector will have different components in differently oriented frames, but the physical relationships are preserved.

3. Motion of the Frame

Perhaps most importantly, reference frames can be moving relative to each other. One frame might be at rest (or moving with constant velocity), while another is accelerating or rotating. This difference in motion leads to different descriptions of the same physical events.

Why Choosing the Right Frame Makes Your Life Easier

Choosing an appropriate reference frame can dramatically simplify mathematical calculations. This is a powerful problem-solving strategies in physics.

Example 1: Projectile Motion

Consider a ball thrown at an angle. In a frame fixed to the ground, the motion involves both horizontal and vertical components, and the equations can be complex. However, if we choose a frame that moves horizontally with the ball's initial horizontal velocity, the ball appears to move only vertically (straight up and down) in this frame, making the analysis much simpler.

Strategies for Simplifying with Reference Frames:
  • Center of mass frame: For systems of particles, choosing a frame where the center of mass is at rest eliminates the overall translational motion, simplifying the analysis of relative motions.
  • Align the frame with the motion: For an object moving in a circle, choosing a frame that rotates with the object can make the object appear stationary, simplifying the analysis. For an object sliding down an incline, it is useful to tilt the frame to match the incline.
  • Frame where one object is at rest: In collision problems, choosing a frame where one object is initially at rest can simplify momentum and energy calculations.
  • Symmetry-aligned frame: Choosing axes that align with the symmetry of a problem (e.g., along the direction of motion or perpendicular to a plane) can reduce the number of non-zero components in vectors.
Example 2: Two-Body Collision

Consider two particles colliding. In the laboratory frame, both particles may be moving, making the analysis complex. However, if we transform to the center-of-mass frame (where the total momentum is zero), the collision becomes symmetric and much easier to analyze. After solving in this frame, we can transform back to the laboratory frame if needed.

Example 3: Circular Motion

A satellite orbiting Earth follows a circular path. In an inertial frame fixed to Earth's center, the satellite's position vector rotates, and we need to account for centripetal acceleration. However, in a frame that rotates with the satellite (a non-inertial frame), the satellite appears stationary, though we must then account for fictitious forces. The choice depends on what we want to calculate.

Inertial Reference Frames

A special and extremely important class of reference frames are inertial reference frames. These frames play a fundamental role in Newtonian mechanics and relativity.

Definition of an Inertial Reference Frame:

An inertial reference frame is a reference frame in which Newton's first law holds: an object with no net force acting on it moves with constant velocity (including zero velocity, i.e., at rest).

Equivalently, an inertial frame is one in which:

  • The frame is not accelerating (it moves with constant velocity or is at rest)
  • The frame is not rotating
  • Newton's laws of motion are valid in their standard form
Key Properties of Inertial Frames:
  • All inertial frames are equivalent: The laws of physics are the same in all inertial frames. This is the principle of relativity.
  • Inertial frames move with constant velocity relative to each other: If frame $A$ is inertial and frame $B$ moves with constant velocity relative to $A$ (without rotation), then $B$ is also inertial.
  • No absolute rest frame: There is no preferred inertial frame. All inertial frames are equally valid for describing physics.
  • Accelerating frames are non-inertial: Frames that are accelerating or rotating are non-inertial and require additional "fictitious" or "inertial" forces (like centrifugal and Coriolis forces) to make Newton's laws work.

Non-Inertial Reference Frames

Any reference frame that is accelerating or rotating is a non-inertial frame. In such frames, objects appear to experience additional forces that don't exist in inertial frames.

Example 4: Accelerating Car

Imagine you're in a car that suddenly accelerates forward. In the frame of the car (a non-inertial frame), you feel pushed backward into your seat. This "force" is actually due to your inertia—your body wants to remain at rest relative to the ground, but the car is accelerating. In an inertial frame fixed to the ground, there's no mysterious backward force; you simply remain at rest while the car accelerates forward.

Example 5: Rotating Frame

On a rotating merry-go-round, objects appear to experience a "centrifugal force" pushing them outward. In an inertial frame (fixed to the ground), there's no such force; the objects are simply moving in straight lines while the merry-go-round rotates beneath them. The apparent outward force is a consequence of analyzing motion in a non-inertial (rotating) frame.

Transformation Between Frames

When we change from one reference frame to another, we need to transform the coordinates and other physical quantities. For inertial frames moving with constant relative velocity, the transformations are relatively simple (Galilean transformations in Newtonian mechanics, Lorentz transformations in special relativity).

Galilean Transformation (for Inertial Frames):

If frame $S'$ moves with constant velocity $\mathbf{v}$ relative to frame $S$, then:

$$\mathbf{r}' = \mathbf{r} - \mathbf{v}t$$
$$t' = t$$

where $\mathbf{r}$ is the position in frame $S$ and $\mathbf{r}'$ is the position in frame $S'$. The velocities transform as:

$$\mathbf{v}' = \mathbf{v} - \mathbf{v}_{\text{frame}}$$

where $\mathbf{v}_{\text{frame}}$ is the velocity of frame $S'$ relative to frame $S$.

Applications and Importance

Understanding reference frames is crucial in many areas of physics:

Summary

Key Takeaways:
  • A reference frame is a coordinate system with an origin, axes, and a clock for measuring positions and times.
  • Frames can differ in origin location, axis orientation, and motion (velocity, acceleration, rotation).
  • Choosing the right frame can dramatically simplify calculations by aligning with symmetries or eliminating unnecessary motion.
  • Inertial frames are those in which Newton's first law holds—frames that are not accelerating or rotating.
  • All inertial frames are equivalent; the laws of physics are the same in all inertial frames.
  • Non-inertial frames require fictitious forces to make Newton's laws work.